Yesterday in San Francisco Blackbaud (Raiser's Edge) bought me a beer at the NTEN conference (technology conference for non-profits). Or rather, CTO Shaun Sullivan did (hi Shaun). He was very complimentary about GiftWorks fundraising software--he had downloaded it a few weeks ago and I wanted to know what he thought--so I offered to show him the upcoming GiftWorks 2006. And he really liked that, too. It was an interesting talk. Christine from Omidyar and Joe Baker from NTen listened in.
I don't think it's fair to get into the whole conversation just yet, but we did talk about our business models. Blackbaud is an enterprise software company for nonprofit organizations, and regardless of what they charge for Raiser's Edge, the cost of ownership is too high for most nonprofits. They serve large nonprofits that can afford the customization, training, and other services Blackbaud offers. We don't.
We are not an enterprise software company and have no plans to be. For four years our mission has been to provide low-cost ($299), easy to use software that helps nonprofits focus more on their missions and less on technology. And from the time we released GiftWorks 1.1 last summer, everyone from customers to industry experts have expressed amazement at the intuitive interface, which we're fairly certain will get copied by others. We've worked very, very hard on making complex things appear simple and easy to use, and it's never, ever easy.
If Blackbaud or Kintera tried to do what we are doing, they'd lose money; you just can't dumb down a product designed for large organizations and make smaller organizations happy, and the larger organizations are likely to want the new lower price regardless of features, cutting into revenues. At the same time, we would have to add a ton of features that only 5% of our customers demand to serve larger nonprofits, plus a lot of services and maintenance charges to service that small group of large enterprise nonprofts. We're not going to do that.
So we compete, but we're not really competing for the same customers. I'm leaving some things out here--we're not revealing everything about what we have planned. No fun in that!
Which leads to competition, open source, and the nonprofit community. Do for-profit businesses serve nonprofits best? Does competition help nonprofits? I think so. I didn't attend the panel on open source, because I was deeply engaged in a conversation about volunteers, but I know there's a lot of belief out there that the open source community can better serve nonprofits, and that free is always better. I don't think so. Open Source has its place. But customers who pay for something have a stake in its evolution, and place reasonable demands on the software maker to improve and maintain the software. And as Shaun said, we have to feed our families, so we work to make sure customers are happy.
One thing nonprofits don't like to do is treat volunteers like they do vendors--if someone is volunteering time, you don't want to tell them you don't want their help or don't like the quality of their work. I'm not saying Open Source efforts won't be successful or of good quality (we are likely to contribute some tech to the open source community), I'm saying the relationship between nonprofits and the community is substantially different than the one between nonprofits and their employees, sofware vendors, phone companies, and other fee-based entities. You can make demands if you pay, and if you don't, you can only make appeals or pleas. The response and results are much different. If you've ever volunteered or worked with volunteers, you know what I'm talking about.
Competition is good for nonprofits, as is nonprofit investment in for-profit efforts to help nonprofits improve their operations. I'm biased--we are a for profit company, but in the service of our nonprofit customers, and we serve them very well for a very low investment. They make demands, we listen, we respond, we improve.
So Shaun, nice talking with you. Maybe we'll compete in a few years, but my bet is we won't be competing for smaller nonprofits--it's just not your business model. And we're happy you like our software--so do we. GiftWorks 2.0 Beta II was posted yesterday.